This must be a manufacturing error -- the label says 2P, but my housemate, who typically wears a 10, is swimming in them and giggling. I like the style and pattern enough that I might have attempted an exchange, except the fabric is so thin that everybody would know if I was wearing my flowered underwear, and the cheap wooden button splintered the first time I eased it through the buttonhole.
Cameron- Scott here. We are so sorry to hear this! Please call us at 866-686-7778 so we can get this worked out!